Most "best headphones" lists rank products as if everyone wants the same thing. In practice, the reviews we read keep returning to the same four questions: how much noise you need to block, which phone you use, whether you want earbuds or over-ears, and how much you'll put up with in exchange for battery life. This guide starts with those questions, then walks through the eight headphones and earbuds we've analyzed in depth, and tells you which one the evidence points to for each kind of buyer.
Quick answers
- Best noise-cancelling over-ears overall: Sony WH-1000XM6 — class-leading ANC and much-improved calls, per TechRadar, Tom's Guide and What Hi-Fi?.
- Strongest noise blocking for flyers: Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen) — see our Sony vs Bose comparison.
- Best value / longest battery over-ears: Anker Soundcore Space Q45, with the Soundcore Space One as the cheaper step down.
- Best premium earbuds: Sony WF-1000XM6, if the fit works for you.
- Best earbuds for iPhone vs Galaxy owners: AirPods Pro 3 vs Galaxy Buds 4 Pro — the deciding factor is your phone (see our head-to-head).
- On-ear pick for battery and calls (no ANC): Beats Solo 4.
Before you buy: the four things that actually decide it
1. How much noise cancelling do you need?
Active noise cancellation (ANC) uses microphones to measure outside sound and plays an inverted signal to cancel it. It works best on steady, low-frequency noise — engine drone, air conditioning, train rumble — and less well on sudden or high-pitched sounds like voices and clattering dishes. That's why reviewers measure it differently: SoundGuys, for example, reports average attenuation across frequencies, and its comparison found the AirPods Pro 3 blocked about 90% on average, while the Galaxy Buds 4 Pro had a weaker spot in the mid-range. If you commute or fly often, ANC strength should be near the top of your list. If you mostly listen at a desk or at home, battery, comfort and sound tuning matter more.
2. Which phone do you use?
This is the single most underrated factor in the reviews we read. Apple's earbuds reserve headline features — automatic device switching, Live Translation and the deepest iOS integration — for iPhone owners. Samsung does the same in reverse: SoundGuys notes that features like the Samsung Seamless Codec, Ultra High-Quality audio and Auracast largely require a recent Galaxy phone. Sony and Anker models are platform-neutral, with full control through their own apps on both iOS and Android.
3. Codecs: what LDAC, AAC and LC3 mean for you
A Bluetooth codec is the format your phone uses to compress audio on its way to the headphones. iPhones use AAC, so higher-bitrate codecs like Sony's LDAC make no difference there. Many Android phones support LDAC, which several of the headphones in this guide offer (the Sony WH-1000XM6, Soundcore Space One and Space Q45 among them). LC3 is the codec behind Bluetooth LE Audio and features like Auracast broadcast listening; support is still rolling out across phones. In practice, reviewers rarely rank headphones on codec alone — fit, tuning and ANC make a bigger audible difference — but if you have an Android phone and care about detail, LDAC support is a reasonable tiebreaker.
4. Over-ear, on-ear or earbuds?
Over-ears generally deliver the strongest ANC and longest battery life because there's room for bigger batteries and better seals. Earbuds win on portability and workouts, but battery per charge is shorter (the WF-1000XM6 is rated around 8 hours with ANC) and fit is more personal — reviewers of Sony's earbuds repeatedly warned that the foam tips don't suit every ear. On-ears like the Beats Solo 4 are lighter and fold small, but they press on the ear rather than around it, and TechRadar's reviewer found that uncomfortable after about an hour.
The headphones and earbuds, one by one
Sony WH-1000XM6 — aggregate score 8.9
The reviews we read put the XM6 at the top for people who want the strongest all-round package. TechRadar and What Hi-Fi? credit its QN3 processor and 12 microphones with class-leading noise cancelling, and Tom's Guide and What Hi-Fi? both note much better call quality than before. It's light at 254 g, the folding hinges are back, and it supports LDAC, LC3 and Auracast. The trade-offs: battery life of about 30 hours with ANC is good rather than class-leading, Tom's Guide found the soundstage narrower than some rivals, and What Hi-Fi? flags that there's no audio over USB-C.
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones (2nd Gen) — via our Sony vs Bose comparison
What Hi-Fi?'s head-to-head picked the Sony on sound quality, but the Bose keeps the "make the world go quiet" crown and offers wired listening over USB-C and adjustable ANC strength, which the Sony lacks. If you fly a lot or care more about silence than detail, the sources lean Bose; at similar prices, most reviewers we read lean Sony.
Anker Soundcore Space Q45 — aggregate score 8.2
The Q45's standout is battery life: SoundGuys measured nearly 56 hours with ANC on, beating Anker's own claim, and its microphone rejects background noise unusually well for the price. Its noise cancelling is good for the money rather than class-leading — SoundGuys' lab score for ANC was below average, while Android Central found it handles low drones well but lets higher-pitched noise through — and SoundGuys found the default sound uneven without EQ.
Soundcore Space One — aggregate score 7.8
A cheaper step down from the Q45 that, per TechRadar, SoundGuys and Tom's Guide, over-delivers on ANC and battery (about 43 hours with ANC on). Out of the box the sound is bass-forward and needs a few minutes of EQ in the app, and calls can get muffled in wind. Our Beats Solo 4 vs Space One comparison found TechRadar scored the Space One higher overall.
Sony WF-1000XM6 — aggregate score 8.7
What Hi-Fi?, Tom's Guide and Android Central all praise its natural, detailed sound, ANC that nearly matches Bose and very good call quality, plus a 10-band EQ and multipoint. All three also criticize the bulky case, and fit is the stumbling block: only four foam tip sizes. Its Amazon owner rating (3.6/5 when we checked) is much lower than the professional consensus, which we read as a reason to buy somewhere with easy returns rather than a reason to dismiss it.
AirPods Pro 3 vs Samsung Galaxy Buds 4 Pro — see the comparison
SoundGuys ran both through the same lab tests. The AirPods Pro 3 had the stronger ANC and longer measured battery life; the Buds 4 Pro scored higher on raw sound quality and offers EQ that AirPods lack. Our conclusion from the sources: iPhone owners should lean AirPods, Galaxy owners should lean Buds 4 Pro, and owners of other Android phones can lean Samsung for EQ flexibility while knowing the Galaxy-only extras won't work.
Beats Solo 4 — aggregate score 7.6
Built around battery life (a 50-hour claim that TechRadar found held up), clean pairing on both iOS and Android, USB-C lossless audio and good call quality. There's no ANC, and TechRadar described its lower mids as muddy and the headband padding as thin. It suits buyers who want a light, stylish on-ear pair for calls and long days rather than the best sound.
Gaming headsets
If you mainly want a headset for PC or console gaming, our SteelSeries Arctis Nova 5 vs HyperX Cloud III S Wireless comparison covers two of the most-recommended mid-price wireless options: the Nova 5 is the software-and-customization pick (TechRadar recommendation, Tom's Guide Editor's Choice), while the Cloud III S is the battery-life pick.
Common questions
Are expensive headphones always better? Not in these reviews. Value models like the Anker Space Q45 and Soundcore Space One win on battery life per dollar, while the priciest models win on noise cancelling and refinement — calls, app features and build — more than on dramatic differences in sound.
Do I need LDAC? Only if you use an Android phone that supports it and listen to high-quality files or streams. iPhone users should ignore codec claims and focus on ANC, fit and comfort.
Earbuds or over-ears for flying? Over-ears, if you can carry them. Both the reviews and the physics favor bigger earcups for blocking low-frequency engine noise and for battery life on long flights.
How do your scores work? Each aggregate score is our editorial synthesis of the published reviews and owner ratings in that product's analysis, not a lab measurement. See how we pick.
Bottom line
For most people who want one pair of premium ANC headphones, the evidence points to the Sony WH-1000XM6; frequent flyers who prize silence over detail should look hard at the Bose. If value and battery life matter most, the Anker Soundcore Space Q45 is a strong pick. For earbuds, let your phone decide: AirPods Pro 3 for iPhone, Galaxy Buds 4 Pro for Galaxy, and the Sony WF-1000XM6 if you want the best platform-neutral sound and can get a good fit.
Sources
- This guide summarizes our individual analyses linked above. Each one lists its own sources in full, including TechRadar, Tom's Guide, What Hi-Fi?, SoundGuys, Android Central and Amazon owner ratings with the dates they were checked.