Both of these serums show up on almost every "best Korean serum" list, both put niacinamide on the front of the box, and both sell for a modest price in a 30 mL dropper bottle. That is where the similarity ends. Anua's Niacinamide 10% + TXA 4% Serum is a targeted brightening treatment built around four pigment-fighting actives. Beauty of Joseon's Glow Serum: Propolis + Niacinamide is mostly propolis — 60% of the formula, per the brand and DermFND — with only 2% niacinamide and a touch of BHA. One is aimed at fading marks; the other at calming skin and making it look healthier. Picking the "stronger" one is the wrong question. The sources we read point to a clearer split: what is your skin's main problem right now?
At a glance
| Anua Niacinamide 10% + TXA 4% Serum | Beauty of Joseon Glow Serum: Propolis + Niacinamide | |
|---|---|---|
| Main job | Fading dark spots, post-acne marks and uneven tone | Calming redness and breakouts; "healthy glow" |
| Headline actives | 10% niacinamide, 4% tranexamic acid, about 2% arbutin + alpha-arbutin, ethyl ascorbic acid (DermFND) | 60% propolis extract, 2% niacinamide, 0.5% betaine salicylate (DermFND) |
| Size | 30 mL | 30 mL (a 60 mL size also exists) |
| Texture | Watery, pink-tinted; slightly tacky finish (The Summer Study) | Honey-like, amber; tacky for 30–60 seconds (DermFND, Mirai Skin) |
| Fragrance | None added | None added; faint natural honey scent |
| Ingredients some acne-prone users watch | Olive, macadamia, jojoba and grape seed oils | Tamanu (calophyllum) oil; propolis (bee-product allergy) |
| DermFND irritation-risk rating | Medium | Medium |
| Independent formula score | DermFND 76/100 | DermFND 78/100 |
| Our aggregate score | 7.9 / 10 | 8.1 / 10 |
| Price | Check current price on Amazon | Check current price on Amazon |
Both scores in the "our aggregate score" row are our editorial synthesis of the sources listed at the bottom of this page, not lab measurements.
Two very different formulas behind the same buzzword
DermFND, an independent ingredient-analysis site that says it accepts no samples, sponsorships or affiliate revenue, describes Anua's serum as a "four-active brightening" system. In its reading, each ingredient targets a different stage of pigmentation. Tranexamic acid at 4% calms the inflammatory signals that tell skin to make excess pigment. Niacinamide at 10% slows pigment transfer to the skin's surface. Arbutin and alpha-arbutin (about 2% combined) inhibit tyrosinase, the enzyme behind melanin production. A stable vitamin C derivative, 3-O-ethyl ascorbic acid, adds antioxidant support. DermFND also notes polyglutamic acid, ceramide NP, panthenol and centella compounds as hydration and barrier support. The pink tint, DermFND says, comes from vitamin B12 (cyanocobalamin), not a dye.
Beauty of Joseon took the opposite approach. DermFND says propolis — the resin bees use to seal their hives — is "the entire foundation" of the Glow Serum at 60%, and it credits propolis with anti-inflammatory and antibacterial activity. The 2% niacinamide is deliberately low, and DermFND argues this is a defensible choice that reduces irritation risk. Betaine salicylate at 0.5% adds gentle BHA-style pore clearing, and tea tree, centella and turmeric extracts round out a calming, anti-blemish profile. In short, the BoJ serum works on breakouts and redness, with brightening as a side benefit. Anua's serum is a brightening treatment with some soothing support added.
That difference shows up in DermFND's own skin-type notes. It lists Anua as best for normal, combination and oily skin, and workable for dry and sensitive skin. It lists the Glow Serum as best for oily, combination and normal skin and "not ideal" for dry skin. Both get a medium irritation-risk rating, for different reasons: high-strength niacinamide in Anua's case, and propolis and BHA in Beauty of Joseon's.
Anua Niacinamide 10% + TXA 4%: what reviewers say
DermFND scores the Anua serum 76/100 (last verified May 2026). It praises the actives at "clinically relevant concentrations," the fragrance- and silicone-free base, and the light, fast-absorbing texture. It also clears up a common point of confusion: Anua added "Dark Spot Correcting" to the name and changed the packaging in 2024, but DermFND says the formula did not change, so either box gets you the same serum. Its reservations are specific. Ten percent niacinamide can cause initial flushing. The olive oil is a potential concern for comedone-prone skin. The 30 mL glass bottle runs out in one to two months with twice-daily use. And deeper or older pigmentation needs months of consistent use plus daily sunscreen.
The Summer Study, a UK beauty blog, reviewed the serum on acne-prone skin. The product was gifted by Anua, which the blogger discloses. After continued evening use, she wrote that pink post-acne marks were fading "much quicker than they normally do." She also found the serum hydrating enough to replace a separate hyaluronic acid step, and said it layered without pilling. Her listed cons were a slightly tacky finish and the possibility that a high niacinamide concentration could irritate some skin. She also pointed out supporting brightening ingredients many shoppers miss: arbutin, alpha-arbutin and ethyl ascorbic acid.
Arktastic, an Australian K-beauty retailer that sells the serum, ran a two-week trial on combination, breakout-prone skin. The reviewer's face flushed on the first application — the reaction DermFND warns about with 10% niacinamide — but it didn't happen again. After about ten days, she reported that her post-breakout marks had healed faster than usual and that her skin looked smoother and more even. She also cautioned that people with oily, sensitive skin risk breakouts and increased reactivity. In her view, the serum's long list of plant extracts and seed oils makes it a poor choice during an active, inflamed breakout. Because Arktastic profits from selling the product, we weight its praise less than the independent sources. Its warnings are more useful because they cut against its own commercial interest.
Beauty of Joseon Glow Serum: what reviewers say
DermFND scores the Glow Serum 78/100 (last verified May 2026), slightly ahead of Anua. It credits the propolis-niacinamide-BHA combination with "a surprisingly comprehensive anti-blemish strategy." It also describes the glow as a healthy luminosity rather than shimmer, and it rates the value highly. On the critical side, DermFND flags a brief tackiness while the serum absorbs, a real allergy risk for anyone sensitive to bee products, and tamanu oil — "a curious inclusion" in a serum otherwise suited to acne-prone skin. It also notes that 2% niacinamide will disappoint anyone who wants high-strength brightening or oil control.
Mirai Skin, a K-beauty retailer that sells the serum, published a four-week review on combination skin with occasional breakouts. The reviewer reported a glowier, more even look by week two, calmer redness around the nose and cheeks, and post-acne marks that lightened (but didn't disappear) by weeks three and four. They described the texture as slightly sticky at first and absorbing within about 30 seconds. Their main criticisms were that the serum isn't moisturizing enough on its own for dry skin and that the 30 mL bottle goes quickly. The review ends with a 4.6/5 verdict. As with Arktastic, this is a seller's review, so we treat it as supporting evidence, not independent confirmation.
jessmeandering, a long-running personal beauty blog whose disclaimer says products are self-purchased unless noted, called the serum one she had nearly finished and "well-loved." She compared its feel to COSRX's snail mucin essence — slightly tacky at first, then quick to absorb — and said it helped even out her skin texture while staying hydrating. The review is short and mostly positive, but it independently confirms the tacky-then-absorbs texture that every other source mentions.
Notably, Arktastic's Anua review compares the two products directly. The reviewer said the Anua serum reminded her of the BoJ Glow Serum's "warm glow," but preferred Anua for her own skin because it also targeted redness and acne scarring.
Anua Niacinamide + TXA — reviewers liked
- Four brightening actives at meaningful strengths (DermFND)
- Post-acne marks faded faster for two reviewers (The Summer Study, Arktastic)
- Watery, fragrance-free, layers without pilling
- Hydrating enough to replace an HA serum for one reviewer
- Same formula in old and new "Dark Spot Correcting" packaging
Anua Niacinamide + TXA — reviewers flagged
- 10% niacinamide can flush or sting at first (DermFND, Arktastic)
- Several plant oils, including olive (comedone caution)
- Not ideal during active, inflamed breakouts (Arktastic)
- Slightly tacky finish; small 30 mL glass bottle
- Older pigmentation and melasma need months plus SPF
BoJ Glow Serum — reviewers liked
- 60% propolis base for calming and anti-blemish care (DermFND)
- Healthy, non-greasy glow (DermFND, Mirai Skin)
- Calmer redness within two weeks for one reviewer
- Gentle 2% niacinamide; fragrance-free
- Strong value; 60 mL size available
BoJ Glow Serum — reviewers flagged
- Tacky for up to a minute (every source we read)
- Avoid if allergic to bee products
- Contains tamanu oil (comedone caution)
- Not moisturizing enough alone for dry skin
- Too mild if dark spots are your main concern
Head-to-head: which should you buy?
For post-acne marks, sun spots or uneven tone: Anua is the more targeted choice. It has four actives aimed at pigment, two reviewers described marks fading faster than usual, and DermFND explicitly positions it for hyperpigmentation and melasma. Expect weeks, not days, and pair it with daily sunscreen — DermFND calls daily sunscreen the most important pairing for any brightening serum.
For redness, irritation and frequent small breakouts: the Beauty of Joseon Glow Serum fits better. Its propolis base, low-dose niacinamide and gentle BHA target inflammation and clogged pores. Mirai Skin's reviewer reported calmer redness by week two.
For sensitive skin that reacts to strong actives: lean toward Beauty of Joseon, but only if you don't react to bee products. The 2% niacinamide is less likely to cause the flushing two Anua sources describe. If you choose Anua, DermFND suggests starting once a day.
For dry skin: neither serum replaces moisturizer. DermFND lists the Glow Serum as not ideal for dry skin, and Mirai Skin agreed it isn't moisturizing enough alone. Anua's polyglutamic acid and hyaluronic acid made it feel more hydrating to The Summer Study's reviewer, so it is the slightly safer bet here.
If you are fungal-acne-prone or watch comedogenic oils: DermFND marks neither formula as fungal-acne-safe. Anua contains several seed oils, including olive; Beauty of Joseon contains tamanu oil. Patch-test either one.
Can you use both? Their main actives target different problems, and none of our sources reports a conflict between them. A common approach is Anua in the evening for marks and the Glow Serum in the morning for calm and glow, with sunscreen on top because of the BHA and brightening actives. Introduce one at a time so you can tell which one your skin reacts to.
How these compare to other serums we've analyzed
If brightening is your main goal and you want a gentler, rice-based option, our Beauty of Joseon Glow Deep Serum analysis covers the Glow Serum's sister product, built around alpha-arbutin rather than propolis. For a vitamin C route to brighter skin, see our COSRX Vitamin C 23 vs Innisfree vitamin C serum comparison. If your skin mainly needs soothing, the SKIN1004 Madagascar Centella Ampoule is a simpler, centella-only alternative.
A note on the sources
Independent long-form coverage of both serums is thinner than their popularity suggests. Most of what turns up in search is retailer listings, user-review platforms and short social posts. To compensate, we anchored the comparison on DermFND's current formula analyses (May 2026) for both products, and we label every source with a commercial tie. Arktastic and Mirai Skin sell these serums. The Summer Study received the Anua serum as a gift. jessmeandering says she bought her own products and links to a retailer with an affiliate code. Where retailer reviews and independent sources agree — tackiness, small bottle size, initial niacinamide flush — we treat the point as well supported.
FAQ
Which serum has more niacinamide?
Anua, by a wide margin: 10% versus 2% in the Beauty of Joseon Glow Serum, according to DermFND. More isn't automatically better, though. The higher dose is what causes the first-use flushing some users report.
Is the Anua "Dark Spot Correcting Serum" different from the "Niacinamide 10% + TXA 4% Serum"?
No. DermFND says Anua renamed and repackaged it in 2024 without changing the formula.
Why does the Beauty of Joseon serum feel sticky?
DermFND attributes the tackiness to the naturally resinous propolis. It suggests applying two or three drops to slightly damp skin. Every reviewer we read said the stickiness fades within about a minute.
Can I use either serum with retinol?
DermFND says the Glow Serum can be layered under retinol, or alternated with it on different nights if your skin gets sensitive. For Anua, it recommends daily sunscreen and a gradual start if you are new to high-strength niacinamide. Introduce strong actives one at a time.
I'm allergic to bees — is the Glow Serum safe?
DermFND and Mirai Skin both advise people with bee-product allergies to avoid it or patch-test very carefully, since propolis is a bee product.
Our take, based on the cross-source analysis
These serums solve different problems, so the right pick depends on your skin. Beauty of Joseon's Glow Serum edges ahead overall (8.1 vs 7.9). DermFND scores its formula slightly higher, it is gentler, and every source agrees it delivers the calm, healthy-looking skin it promises. Its biggest drawbacks are tackiness and the bee-product allergy risk. Anua's Niacinamide 10% + TXA 4% Serum is the stronger tool for dark spots and post-acne marks, with two reviewers reporting faster fading. It loses points for first-use flushing, its seed-oil content, and less independent coverage. Both scores are our own editorial synthesis of the sources below, not lab measurements.
Related analyses
- Beauty of Joseon Glow Deep Serum analysis — the brand's rice and alpha-arbutin serum, a gentler brightening alternative to Anua's four-active formula.
- COSRX Vitamin C 23 vs Innisfree vitamin C serum — two vitamin C serums for anyone who prefers that route to brighter skin.
- SKIN1004 Madagascar Centella Ampoule analysis — a minimal centella ampoule for redness-prone skin that doesn't want propolis or high-dose niacinamide.
- Anua Heartleaf 77 vs Round Lab Dokdo toner — Anua's best-known soothing toner, a common step before either serum.
Sources referenced for this analysis
- DermFND — independent ingredient and formula analysis of the Anua Niacinamide 10% + TXA 4% Serum, 76/100 (last verified May 2026; states no samples, sponsorships or affiliate revenue).
- DermFND — independent ingredient and formula analysis of the Beauty of Joseon Glow Serum: Propolis + Niacinamide, 78/100 (last verified May 2026).
- The Summer Study — Anua Niacinamide 10% + TXA 4% Serum review (July 2025; product gifted by Anua, disclosed; blog uses affiliate links).
- Arktastic — two-week Anua Niacinamide TXA Serum review (May 2025; Arktastic is a K-beauty retailer that sells the product).
- Mirai Skin — four-week Beauty of Joseon Glow Serum review (March 2026; Mirai Skin is a K-beauty retailer that sells the product).
- jessmeandering — Beauty of Joseon Glow Serum review (March 2025; blog states products are self-purchased unless noted; includes a retailer affiliate code).
